Can estate agents lie about other offers in the UK?
Estate agents are expected to act with integrity, but not all do. Some may mislead buyers by exaggerating or fabricating the existence of competing offers. This can pressure buyers into making higher bids or quicker decisions. While suggesting that other interest exists is not illegal, inventing a non-existent offer is a serious offence under the Fraud Act 2006 and can breach the Estate Agents Act 1979. Buyers need to understand their rights and the signs that may indicate dishonest practices in property negotiations.
What qualifies as misleading in estate agency practice?
Misleading statements are often subtle. For instance, an agent might say “we have strong interest” when no actual offers exist. These statements create urgency without offering factual clarity. If an agent invents another buyer to extract a higher bid, this crosses the line into fraudulent misrepresentation.
What does the law say about false offers?
The Estate Agents Act 1979 outlines the legal responsibilities of estate agents in the United Kingdom. It requires agents to pass on all offers to the seller in writing and to act in the client’s best interests. The Fraud Act 2006 further criminalises any false representation made to gain financially or to cause a loss to someone else. These regulations ensure transparency in housing transactions and protect consumers from dishonest conduct.
How are estate agents regulated?
All estate agents operating in the UK must be registered with a government approved redress scheme such as The Property Ombudsman or the Property Redress Scheme. These organisations investigate complaints and can impose penalties, including expulsion from the scheme and compensation to affected parties. Agents must also comply with guidelines from National Trading Standards.
Get an Honest Property Valuation
Tired of inflated promises and vague estimates? At Barrain Estate Agents, we provide straightforward and honest valuations you can trust.
Why do some agents fabricate offers?
Unethical agents may fabricate offers to accelerate the sale or to increase their commission. Creating the illusion of demand can convince a buyer to act more quickly or raise their offer. This dishonest tactic, known as a phantom offer, undermines the trust that buyers place in the negotiation process.
How can you tell if an estate agent is being dishonest?
There are signs that may help you identify dishonest behaviour. Inconsistent communication, sudden urgency with no prior interest, and refusal to offer proof of other offers can all be warning signs. If a property has been on the market for several weeks without activity, sudden claims of multiple offers should be approached with caution.
For a more detailed guide on how to verify property values and recent sales, you can read our article on how to check sold house prices in your area.
Can you ask to see proof of another offer?
Yes, you can ask. While estate agents are bound by data protection regulations and may not reveal full details, they can confirm general aspects. For instance, whether the offer is from a chain-free buyer or someone with a mortgage in principle. Redacted written confirmation can add reassurance that the interest is genuine.
Report Concerns or Get a Second Opinion
Not sure if your current estate agent is being upfront? Our team is happy to review your situation and offer a second opinion without obligation.
Should you speak to the seller’s solicitor?
Buyers can ask the seller’s solicitor to verify whether other offers exist. Solicitors are regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority and must follow a professional code of conduct. Although they represent the seller, they are less likely to be deceptive due to their legal obligations.
What is a phantom offer?
A phantom offer is a false claim made by an estate agent that another buyer has submitted an offer. The purpose is to increase urgency or push a higher bid. This tactic is unethical and can result in formal complaints or legal consequences for the agent involved.
How does market context affect the likelihood of multiple offers?
Understanding local property market trends can help determine the likelihood of multiple bids. In a sellers’ market where demand exceeds supply, it is common for properties to receive several offers. In slower markets, exaggerated claims of buyer competition may be less credible. Buyers should use property portals to review how long a home has been listed and whether the price has changed recently.
You can also visit our article on how long it takes to sell a house in the UK for insights on market timing and what it reveals about demand.
What are your options if you suspect a fake offer?
If you feel that an estate agent has fabricated an offer, document all communication including emails, phone calls, and property listings. Submit a complaint first to the agency. If unresolved, escalate the matter to The Property Ombudsman or the Property Redress Scheme. Both organisations can carry out a full investigation and offer compensation if misconduct is confirmed.
For severe misconduct or repeated breaches, report the matter to your local Trading Standards office. This government body can enforce legal penalties and prohibit dishonest agents from operating.
What are lockout agreements and should you consider one?
A lockout agreement is a contract that prevents the seller from negotiating with other buyers for a set period. This gives the buyer exclusive rights to proceed with the transaction. It offers peace of mind while mortgage arrangements and surveys are completed. These agreements must be negotiated fairly and involve a solicitor.
What is a non refundable deposit agreement?
A non refundable deposit agreement is when a buyer puts down money that they lose if they withdraw from the transaction. This shows strong intent to complete the purchase. However, buyers must assess their readiness before entering such an agreement, especially if legal or financial hurdles remain.
Speak to a Local Estate Agent Who Knows London
Our team knows what sells and what stalls in your postcode. Let’s talk about how we can help attract serious buyers to your listing.
What should buyers avoid sharing?
Buyers should avoid revealing their maximum budget to an estate agent. Doing so can expose them to inflated bidding strategies or pressure to increase their offer. It is better to make offers based on current market data and comparable sales.
Our guide to making an offer on a house provides more detail on this strategy.
What steps should sellers take to avoid misinformation?
Sellers should ask to see all offers in writing and request updates from their agent after each viewing. Requesting details such as whether a buyer is chain free or has a mortgage in principle can help evaluate the seriousness of the offer.
Sellers should also request a clear written agreement with the agent, outlining obligations and expectations. This ensures accountability if the relationship breaks down.
Why choosing a regulated agent matters
Working with a registered estate agent who is a member of a redress scheme ensures a higher level of professionalism. These agents are trained in consumer protection law and are held to a strict code of conduct.
At Barrain Estate Agents, we follow the TPO Code of Practice. We verify all offers and provide written confirmation to our clients. Our goal is to create trust by being open and transparent at every step.
How does Barrain Estate Agents protect buyers and sellers?
We log all offers and verify the buyer’s position before presenting it to the seller. We ensure that buyers are fully informed and that sellers receive accurate information. We believe that good advice comes from facts, not pressure tactics.
Summary
Estate agents are legally and professionally bound to act fairly and honestly. While most follow these rules, some use misleading tactics to influence buyers. By asking the right questions, requesting evidence, and working with a reputable agent, you can avoid falling for dishonest practices and make confident decisions during the property buying or selling process.
FAQs
Can I ask to see proof of another offer? Yes, you can. The agent should confirm general details such as buyer position or offer type, even if exact information is not shared.
What is the risk of phantom offers? Phantom offers are rare but damaging. They can cause buyers to overpay or act under pressure. Spotting them early protects your interests.
Can I reduce my offer later if I feel misled? Yes. Offers are not binding until contracts are exchanged. You may adjust your offer at any point based on new information or concerns.
How do I file a complaint against an estate agent? First raise your concern with the estate agency. If not resolved, contact The Property Ombudsman or Property Redress Scheme with your documentation.
Should I work with agents offering in house services? Some agents may promote in house mortgage advisors or solicitors. Always assess whether these services are genuinely beneficial or if they come with added pressure or conflicts of interest.
